Fan Reviews

Stafford, Virginia: Most pleased to see and hear them all together and performing many of their songs in a way I remember listening to in my college days. I found myself applauding, laughing and crying all at the same time. Their harmonies were still the draw for me and I was not disappointed. Acoustic guitar work by Stills and Crosby was wonderful. Nash can still add the energy of his high vocal range and of course Young was there to not only please with powerful guitar runs, but he pleased the MCI crowd with all his movement and concentration on each piece. My children were with me, and they enjoyed as much as I.

Falls Church, Virginia: Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young -CSNY- gave a long -more than three hour- and high-spirited performance at the MCI Centre tonight. Many of their songs were filled with fine lead vocals -with each member taking a turn- spiced with beautiful harmonies -such as "Guinnevere," and Suite: Judy Blue Eyes"-. Other songs were laced with stirring guitar work by Stills, or Young, or both -such as "Love the One You're With," and "Down By the River"-. CSNY joyfully brought out their fine tapestry of songs from their solo careers and their groups' various incarnations -from the Byrds to their present CSNY album-. The MCI sound system pitched in with clarity throughout the concert, and the concert ended with Young's guitar lying on the stage with all of its strings popped, yet still being played--a fine ending to an excellent concert.

Annapolis, MD: Great concert. I felt like I was back in the 60's again. the band was tight and Neil Young still plays a mean guitar.

Bethesda, Maryland: Having seen the four last in 1974 in Arrowhead stadium, after two other groups, and falling asleep -My husband will NEVER let me live this down- the concert tonight was hopping. It started a little slow, it takes more to get us grey haired groupies going, but soon CSNY and the crowd were going. The lights were shining in our face for a period of time, which was quite annoying, the music helped calm them. The acoustic pieces were better than in 74; Ohio, makes me cry every time, but a great song, and Down by the River -is that song about heroin or what?- Stephen Stills played the guitar fantastically, along with Neil Young. David Crosby's voice was in fine form. And Graham was the glue.

Washington, DC: The old saying "It ain't over 'til the fat lady sings" should now be replaced by "It ain't over 'til Neil lays down his guitar!!!" The show at MCI Centre was spectacular! All four seemed rejuvenated by their songs and jams, and where they lacked in technical proficiency, they clearly made up for it in their energy and enthusiasm. Graham Nash's songs were the only ones that sounded dated to me, but I have to admit I was never a big fan of his songs to begin with. However, his duet with Crosby on Guinivere was outstanding. He also added nicely to one of the highlight songs of the night for me - Neil's After the Goldrush, which was done so amazingly with the organ and Crosby-Nash on backing vocals. I think the three songs in that set -- After the Goldrush, Guinivere, and Suite Judy Blue Eyes -- must have given the multitudes of long-time fans -including me- a wonderful flashback and joyful feeling! Only one song I really expected to hear -- Wooden Ships -- wasn't included. I didn't want the show to end.

Baltimore, MD: The show was, indeed, even better than I expected.

I'm not as taken was Young's l-e-n-g-t-h-y guitar solos as I was in the old druggie days, but the energy was great, the sounds were fun, it was nostalgic, without being totally bogged down in the good-ole-days -I liked nearly all of the new stuff-, and I am very glad I was there.

One of the best shows I've seen in years.

Reston, VA: Unbelievable, Neil is awesome. That old man can sure jam. WOW! Excellent excellent show. I give it a 11.

Owing, Maryland: It was nostalgia night for my husband and I. It was awesome to see and hear talent from 4 great men--who finally put the past behind them and came together in the spirit of entertaining and bringing vitality and energy to the gifts that each of them possess. I hope they continue with their tour and stay together--it's obvious that they belong together--to use the gifts and talents that God has richly blessed them with.

Stafford, VA: My husband and I took our two young children to the show. We were thrilled at the enthusiasm of the group. Many people agreed with us that they seemed at ease with each other and their song. We were amazed at the energy they exuded, not the 50 plus age they really are. We remarked that it was a bit loud for our children who kept their ears covered, but they also enjoyed the music and eventually fell asleep, not even roused by the numerous energetic ovations of the audience. All in all, by far one of the best -and longest- concerts we have ever been to. Well worth the money.

Silver Spring, MD: Where were all of the members of CSNY born? I know Crosby played in Buffalo Springfield and the Byrds -- did Neil Young also play in Buffalo Springfield? How did Young end up with CSN -- was it at Woodstock for the first time? Was the Hollies the first band for Nash?

Washington, DC: I wasn't sure what to expect but because Neil Young was on the bill, I didn't care. Being hopelessly nostalgic I teared up when they played "Carry On" and "Old Man" did me in. I was impressed by the harmonies, the camaraderie and spirit. Stephen Still's played the guitar at times like a Mandolin and I never knew that Crosby played that beautiful guitar on "Guinnevere". I stood for most of the concert and sang along with most of the songs. My only disappointment was they didn't play "Keep on Rockin' in the Free World". Neil Young is a god.

Reston, Virginia: CSNY2K last night at the wonderful MCI Centre was a true "Blast from the Past". After starting out with way too loud audio, the sound person quickly adjusted the amps to a great level for the rest of the show. It was amazing to me how great the acoustics are in this mammoth building...perhaps it had a lot to do with what was playing!

The show was highlighted by an over 15 minute version of "Down by the River" which was almost exclusively Neil Young. What a fabulous treat for all in the crowd as they either danced in the aisles or swayed to the music. Hard to believe this band hasn't toured as a group since 1974.

Annapolis, MD: As a child of the '60s CSN&Y was always a favourite. Last night's concert proved that adoration wasn't misplaced. The music brought me back to a time before kids, divorces, mortgage payments and pressure jobs. I loved it. Ohio brought tears to my eyes when I remembered the emotion of the times.

For me last night reinforced a belief that I have held for some time, Old fat men can still rock and roll.

Scott Duncan, Springfield, VA: Awesome show. I have seen CSN three times previously but the addition of Neil Young really created an explosive atmosphere. These guys still rock!!!

Manassas, Virginia: The music rocked! That was one of the best shows I've ever seen! The stage was set-up with candles and sage burning. And the Indian head, Wow! What I loved most about the show is the passion. I felt like I could have been back in the late 60's and would have still felt the same way! Neil Young whaled like I never would have dreamt off and David Crosby played the song from their new album -which is an unbelievable C.D.!- about his son. The only disappointment was that the crowd did not stand during "Stand and be Counted." You'd think that if there was one song that stood for so much it was that one, and I only saw me and my boy friend standing. We had killer floor seats. Steven Stills would have enjoyed playing at the Nissan Pavilion considering he lived out in Manassas once. He sounded great as ever. And Nash, that man has such a lovely voice, soul and spirit. I was proud to be in their presence. God bless all of them and their families, and may they always stand for what they believe in. They are an encouragement to this world- a world that 'might' spin out of control if we don't take care of our mother earth and our brothers and sisters. :- Thank you CSNY for a lovely evening!

Hamilton, VA: I have seen CSN at least 3 times before and I am never disappointed. These guys rock -notably Neil Young-wow!-like they are "four and twenty years ago"! I still love their harmonies and terrific on-stage camaraderie. They appeared to genuinely love what they are doing and have a blast together. Hat's off to CSNY in the 21st Century-you made me feel like a kid again.

Richmond, VA: It was incredible, stupendous and I was not under the influence of anything except the music. The crowd was great, then venue was good -they should provide an area for the dreaded smokers-. The music was just what I thought it would be. These guys have never let me down in concert. It was fun!

Annandale, Virginia: Damn right!! CSNY can still do it and their youthful enthusiasm created a great and powerful concert. Neil Young is still one of the great American rock icons and when is he going to tour with Crazy Horse again? Getting old doesn't mean getting lame!! It was an exceptional performance.

North Bethesda, Maryland: I'm 30 years old, as one of the fans in the front row so eloquently put it...thanks for the memories! I was 5 when my mom took me to see them the last time they toured, and at 30 can understand why they shaped a generation.

Usually at concerts when new music is trucked out I run for the bathroom, however, Stephen's new song really hit home with what we have to look forward to in the 21st century!

High school brought long weekend nights listening to Neil's unbelievable guitar riffs. I've seen Neil with Crazy Horse, and CS&N many, many times, but to sum it up in one word "outstanding." I will keep going to concerts until the people I love to see are no longer with us! "Keep on rockin' in the free world..."

Rockville, Maryland: I can only say one thing: Neil, Neil, Neil. Bravo!!!!!!

Washington, DC: Wow those guys got old! Neil Young was fantastic. I agree with the reviewer that without him, there would be no life left whatsoever in the other guys. Nash still has some of his voice left. He can still hit some of the sweet high notes.

But Stills and Crosby seem to have completely lost it. Stills' voice is way off key, and he just can't sing anymore. Crosby didn't sound too good, but didn't sound too bad either. Just a big old fat guy who thinks he's hot stuff b-c he fathered Melissa Etheridge's Lesbian love children.

Verdict -- The Neil Young stuff was great, everything else wasn't too good.

Odenton, MD: Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young proved that they can still sing and play with the best of them. While their harmonizing was not perfect, it was still great. Their music went beyond performance. It took you to a place where you could relive a reality that was 30 years ago. You could remember where you were and what you were doing and where you lived and what you were feeling about just about anything that was going on then. It was a powerful experience led by men who played with a vigour and a spirit associated with those times. They were transcendent.

McLean, Virginia: I came looking for nostalgia. What I got was excitement, joy, and a sing-along voice I hadn't heard from myself in too many years. Grudgingly, while I have to admit that not all of the four had kept their youthful range, the harmonies were magical enough so that my 30 year-old sense of what they sounded like washed over any present day flaws. "Ohio, "Almost Cut my Hair," and "Cinnamon Girl" might well have sated my seemingly unquenchable appetite for the old stuff, but three hours of this was almost more than a middle aged man like myself could reasonably have hoped for. At times I wondered if Neil Young's extended riffs were really good or just plain excessive. Of course, 30 years ago, I never would have asked such a question.

Bravo!

Alexandria, Virginia: Wasn't just a "geezers of rock" show. Crosby, Stills and Nash are a high-wire act. Add Neil Young to the mix and you effectively remove the safety net. He brings the edginess that they lack on their own. A once in a life-time experience and at the age of 44 I'm glad I had the chance.

Charles Town WV: It's been twenty five years since I have seen a concert that for me, finally rates higher than a show I saw in 1974. I have probably been to over 100 different musician's concerts since then and none have come close. The concert in 74' was also: CSNY. This show had only a few additional songs, a few high notes that were tough to hit and a few songs that were tuned to a lower key to save voices. But that doesn't matter. Those adjustments are are easily overlooked when the same energy, enthusiasm and fun still resides after 25 years of all sorts of struggles these guys have gone through. They are rock icons and legends of our time in Rock & Roll. They are the closest thing in Rock & Roll history that we will ever have to a "Beatle-type" reunion. Last night gave those who attended a view into that window of history that may never come again. Young's great songs and energy, Still's superb guitar riffs spilled over from his days playing with Hendrix, Nash's clean high-noting hitting voice and Crosby's "father-like" leadership image, and that of one whose respect and experience is like no other. -he sat in on and helped the making of the Beatle's --A Day in A Life--- Cleveland needs to open a big door in the Rock & Roll hall of fame when these guys get inducted. What a great show.

More Here

No part of this site may be reproduced or used without the written permission of the Webmaster.